+ Word must be in search result. - Words must not be in search result. * Word start/end on characters before/after symbol. ""Words in quotes will be searched as phrase.

 

Ukraine adopts new procedure on advance pricing agreements for transfer pricing purposes

author: Ivan Shynkarenko

source: "MNE Tax"

19 November, 2021 Press

A new procedure applicable to advance pricing agreements for transfer pricing purposes, adopted by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on October 28, will become effective in Ukraine on January 1, 2022. The government developed the procedure (adopted by Resolution #1114) in pursuance of the amendments to the Ukrainian tax code introduced by Law 466-IX and in force since May 2020.

The tax code has included rules enabling advance pricing agreements between taxpayers and tax authorities since the introduction of the transfer pricing rules into the Ukrainian tax landscape in 2013. However, Ukraine has yet to see a successful agreement on advance pricing for transfer pricing control purposes. Taxpayers are cautious in applying for this opportunity, which entails massive disclosure of sensitive tax-related information to the tax authorities.

Likely due to this lack of successful advance pricing cases, the government makes periodic overhauls of the regulations. And the current version of the rules provides for several visible improvements, although it still contains major flaws.

The procedure contains a clear statement that any information, documents, or materials, obtained by the tax office at any stage of the advance agreement process cannot be disclosed or promulgated. Moreover, such data cannot be used in any tax control measures including in transfer pricing audits.

The procedure also clarifies the rules of engaging foreign tax authorities under the agreement, which should be done according to the relevant double tax treaty between Ukraine and the state of the respective tax authority.

According to the procedure, taxpayers have the right to apply for preparatory consideration of the advance pricing agreement by the state tax service. This is a kind of probing stage, during which taxpayers can discuss with the tax officers their transfer pricing situation and their vision of the probable approach to the agreement.

The procedure stipulates clear timelines for the tax authorities. Namely, the tax office has 10 workdays from the application to invite the taxpayer for preparatory consideration. The result of the consideration must be provided within 60 calendar days following the application.

The result does not require the taxpayer or the tax authority to follow through with other steps of the process and sign the advance pricing agreement.

The full-fledged procedure for an advance pricing agreement is significantly more complex and lengthier. Yet, even in this case, the procedure tries to set some timelines for avoiding delays by the tax officers. For instance, the tax authority must conduct the first joint discussion within 30 calendar days following the application.

The procedure provides the tax authority with significant rights during consideration of the application that are similar to the rights during transfer pricing audits. Such rights include information requests, visiting and reviewing the taxpayer’s premises, and questioning of the taxpayer’s personnel.

If it is necessary, the tax authority, upon consent of the taxpayer, has the right to engage independent experts. The taxpayer must cover the costs.

The procedure may result in either the tax authority’s refusal to enter an agreement or its readiness to do so.

The advance pricing agreement is concluded for up to five years. However, such an advance pricing agreement may not provide a lot of benefits to the taxpayer in terms of predictability. The procedure establishes that concluded advance pricing agreement may be amended, among other things, in the event of changes in legislation that impact the transfer pricing matters of the taxpayer. Considering almost annual changes of the transfer pricing rules in Ukraine, the discussion of amendments to the advance pricing agreement may become a periodic and burdensome exercise for the taxpayer.

Moreover, the tax authority has the right to terminate the agreement, for instance, in cases in which it believes that the taxpayer has acted not in line with the advance pricing agreement. According to the procedure, such termination is retroactive, i.e., effective from the day that the agreement took effect. Hence, in cases of such termination, the agreement will not provide any protection for the taxpayer.

Last but not least, the taxpayer will have to annually file a report on its performance of the advance pricing agreement. And this report does not substitute for regular transfer pricing reporting. Thus, entering the agreement, if the taxpayer succeeds, will bring more compliance efforts for the future, not less.

These rules can hardly be viewed as friendly to taxpayers. Rather, they signal a lack of trust on the tax administrators’ part.

In this situation, it is likely that we will still have to wait for the first advance pricing agreement to finally happen in Ukraine.

At the same time, the preparatory consideration of the application for advance pricing agreement, as established by the procedure, may be a potentially interesting instrument for the management of transfer pricing–driven risks in Ukraine. It may allow understanding the position of the tax authority towards the transfer pricing methodology and pricing applied by the taxpayer and improve it when necessary. Hence it may be recommended to pay attention to this new opportunity.

Download pdf-file of the article (409 Kb)

Views 430

SIMILAR POSTS

Ukraine Ministry of Finance clarifies general tax consultation on deemed dividends 01 October, 2021    761

Ministry of Finance of Ukraine clarifies some TP issues 16 June, 2021    1348

Ukraine’s new transfer pricing rules expand taxpayer obligations 19 May, 2021    7057

Changes regarding form of the Report on controlled transactions and the Order of its filling 25 March, 2021    785

New rules on business purpose in Ukraine
Test introduced in 2020 has been revised with effect from 2021
09 March, 2021    1073

Country-by-Country Reporting: Form and procedure of submission 05 March, 2021    1490

Transfer Pricing reporting for 2020: what else you should know 19 February, 2021    942

The Coca-Cola’s billion dollar loss in Transfer Pricing dispute with US tax authorities over royalties, or why taxpayers shouldn’t be overoptimistic about agreements with the state 17 February, 2021    1255

Thank you for not approving it on the 31th of December! The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine has approved a list of raw-material goods that fall under the TP scope 16 December, 2020    1548

The Law No. 466-IX stipulates that the income of individuals from certain transactions with investment assets is calculated at normal prices. What does it mean? 16 October, 2020    1114

New proportionate TP adjustment rules introduced into Ukrainian tax law since May 2020 06 October, 2020    840

Another reincarnation of the special TP rules regarding raw materials. Will it work this time? 09 September, 2020    2748

Comment