+ Word must be in search result. - Words must not be in search result. * Word start/end on characters before/after symbol. ""Words in quotes will be searched as phrase.

 

Criminal proceedings on tax evasion in 2018 – what was year-end closing?

26 March, 2019 Newsletters

For a number of years now, the criminal proceedings on tax evasion has been constant companions of tax audits of business, as demonstrated both by the official statistics of General Prosecutor’s Office1 and according to our observations (see infoletters “White collar” crimes in connection with taxes”, “Criminal proceedings on tax evasion: summary statistics for 2017”, “Criminal proceedings on tax evasion: statistics and verdicts within first half of 2018” and others).

As we raised in infoletter “White collar” crimes in connection with taxes”, according to statistics data there were registered 1 688 criminal proceedings on tax evasion in 2018. Such index is bigger than the index of registered criminal proceedings on tax evasion in 2017 by 27 %:

Given such number of registered criminal proceedings only 39 of them were transferred to court for court consideration, which in percentage correlation does not exceed 2,4 %.

Such indexes demonstrate that criminal proceedings under art. 212 of Criminal code of Ukraine (hereinafter referred to as “CC of Ukraine”) remain most likely the method of pressure and harassment of tax payers like it was earlier, that actual mechanism of prosecution for tax evasion. Besides, such correlation accentuates that effective version of art. 212 of CC of Ukraine has issues with quality, that might, inter alia, confirm the fact of its unconstitutionality (see infoletter “The importance of being consistent”).

Subsequent to the results of court consideration of criminal proceedings the number of approved tax evasion is even less. Thus, according to Unified state register of court decisions, 23 verdicts were delivered in 2018, in particular, 14 judgements of conviction, 8 of which were based on plea agreements, and 9 verdicts of no guilty. Such number in general and on each individual category is 57,4 % less then in 2017. It can be discernible on graphs below:

In general, as well as it was earlier, the main array of cases on tax evasion, considered in court is related to so called “fictitious sale operation”, where the subsumption of relevant situations is increasingly made with concurrent elements of crime, including art. 358 and art. 366 of CC of Ukraine. So that, the subsumption under concurrent articles was made in 5 of 12 court decisions in criminal proceedings on tax evasion.

Detailed description of all decision in 2018 is attached in Annex hereof.

We invite to fix on the analysis of the most interesting court decisions, delivered within last quarter of 2018.

So that in case No. 361/2189/15-к2 regarding the director of an enterprise, who was accused in tax evasion and concurrent forgery, concluded by documentational conduction of fictitious deeds, the court delivered a verdict of not guilty. The court brought attention to the fact, that the enterprise appealed the conclusions of act of audit (which was the basis of accusation) and the deeds were not adjudicated as fictitious.

Besides, the Court stated aside, that the essentials of criminal responsibility lies in the fact, that it occurs not as a result of the fact of non-payment of taxes and other obligatory fees but as a result of evasion from fulfillment of abovementioned obligation.

Another non-guilty verdict in case No. 325/22/14-к3 is also worth noticing, where the court stated, that agreements were not adjudicated in a judicial proceeding as void (fictitious). Accordingly, the conclusions of act of audit on fictitiousness of such agreements were not taken into consideration by the court. The court also considered the results of consideration of administrative dispute on appeal of tax assessment and consequently the fact of its cancelation.

It should be noted at long last, that in general both the outcome and efficiency of criminal proceedings on tax evasion remains on the low level. So that, the overall amount of tax evasion, considered in courts is 51 381 323, 27 UAH4 provided that only 8 462 372 UAH amounting only 16,46 % from total amount of evasion were adjudged to reimbursement.

As far as we can see, the statistics of criminal proceedings on tax evasion confirms the reasonability of revision of current version of art. 212 of CC of Ukraine and procedures of work of bodies of pre-trial investigation.

The above commentary presents the general statement for information purposes only and as such may not be practically used in specific cases without professional advice.

Notes:

1According to official statistics of General Prosecutor’s Office of Ukraine.

2Available in USRCD by reference.

3Available in USRCD by reference.

4Exclusive of evasion, adjudicated by courts in 2017 in case on unlawful use of the customs processing regime – see our infoletter “Criminal proceedings on tax evasion: summary statistics for 2017”.

Kind regards,

© WTS Consulting LLC, 2019

Views 1990

SIMILAR POSTS

Criminal proceedings regarding tax evasion: what has changed during the work of the Bureau of Economic Security of Ukraine? 21 March, 2022    286

“Let’s go!”: The Bureau of Economic Security of Ukraine has started its activity 01 December, 2021    947

Tax police performance before liquidation.
Statistics of criminal proceedings regarding tax evasion for the first half of 2021
06 September, 2021    693

Statistics of criminal proceedings for tax evasion for the first quarter of 2021 31 May, 2021    1468

Thresholds of criminal liability under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine in 2021 15 March, 2021    36295

No guilt illusion while closing criminal proceedings due to expiration of limitation periods 10 March, 2021    14520

Statistics of criminal proceedings on taxes for 2020: Goodbye, the tax police! Hello, the Bureau of Economic Security of Ukraine! 17 February, 2021    1414

Statistics of criminal proceedings under Art. 212 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine for three quarters of 2020 24 November, 2020    2834

Statistics of criminal proceedings under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (“Tax evasion”) for the first half of 2020 28 July, 2020    2541

Statistics of criminal proceedings on taxes for 2019 31 January, 2020    2569

Thresholds of criminal liability under Art. 212 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine starting from January 1, 2020 14 January, 2020    44222

Updating! False start. Increased liability on tax evasion
and some other crimes,
and
some other important changes of the Law on Amendments on Simplifying the Pre-Trial Investigation of Certain Categories of Criminal Offences
20 December, 2019    2157

Comment